Re: only getting 12.10 volts when running
Posted: Sun Jul 17, 2011 1:26 pm
General ill health and lack of maintenance in your charging system is usually the cause:jetblack wrote:So, i'm intreigued to know how this happens. Can anyone clarfiy whats gone on for me?
- The first root cause of most issues is often poor earthing. Either the main earth from the loom to the chassis, or the battery terminal earth (either end). Keep these clean, and lubed with silicon (di-electric) grease.
- If that is not your cause, then it's probably green corrosion build-up in the plugs between either the loom and the regulator, or the loom and the alternator. The green build-up causes increased resistance in these plugs (which are already only just big enough for the current involved), which usually then takes out the regulator. When the regulator goes, it will usually take out the battery next, and then the alternator. If you clean them up and stuff with silicon grease, you will not have this problem.
- If that wasn't your problem, then it was the regulator overheating. This can happen on bikes with powdercoated subframes, as the powdercoat insulates the frame so the regulator cannot evacuate heat out the back into the frame. The solution to that is fitting a finned regulator so heat can escape out the front of the unit instead. Also dirt and occasionally corrosion can get in at the back of the regulator, causing the same problem. Air gaps are your enemy here, so if the mounting plate is bent you also have a problem. If you clean it and fill with silicon grease, you won't have that problem. Usually though, regulators melting is a symptom, not the cause. If you find you need a new regulator, you would be daft not to do the other checks above.
- I think it's quite rare for alternators to just fail on their own? I have never seen it except where caused by a failed regulator or a dodgy alternator connector. Although I guess it would be possible for it to just overheat, that'd potentially be caused by running at idle for far too long, and/or having old oil that could maybe deposit (metallic, conducting) sludge on the windings. Again though, that's only theoretical and I have only seen failed generators in conjunction with something else as the cause.
- I suspect a failed battery (eg. if it fails by a cell shorting out rather than just by the acid losing potency and not holding a charge any more) might also have potential to be its own root cause. Hard to diagnose accurately, as in cases where the regulator fails it'll take the battery out quickly, so you won't know which gave up first. In any case, if your battery is "going" then don't let it wait til payday, change it now, or it may just take out the rest of your charging system. As a guide, expect cheap batteries to last about 2 winters, and Yuasa batteries to last up to 4.