Re: NC30 ground lead
Posted: Mon Sep 08, 2014 4:12 am
Not sure what the intention was of the link, doubt a few indiscriminately added earth wires are going to do much good.
I am sure that all on this forum would recommend that any mechanical problem is best fixed by repairing the cause, not adding a band-aid. Same goes for electrical problems.
Below I offer an analysis of the merit of the improvements listed in this post, could ask the same from the proponents.
If a lead connected between the engine and the frame somehow fixes an electrical problem, I would be more concerned why the engine to frame mounting points are not providing an adequate electrical connection. Same applies to the starter motor, if one has to add an earth wire between motor and frame then the quality of the mounting should be questioned. Ignition coil mounting bolts have no electrical contact with the ignition system, so adding an earth at these points has no effect.
Only a few components on an NC30/35 rely on an earth through the engine to fame connection. Unless the various mechanical components have become detached from each other, there is no merit in the added earth wiring.
The loom earth wire provides the majority the return points for the electrical components. The reliability of the wiring loop of an NC30/35, or any other bike/car for that matter, should be better that most of the other components of the vehicle, provided that it is well designed and maintained.
Older bikes I suspect could be more reliable than the newer products in the regard, as I believe the internal joins were soldered, whereas the newer versions are crimped. Should the loom be exposure to water, the solder joints will prove better than the crimped type.
Adding extra earth wires might be cheap and simple but if of no benefit, why? Can anyone identify a problem that was cured with this approach, I would be interested to know.
I am sure that all on this forum would recommend that any mechanical problem is best fixed by repairing the cause, not adding a band-aid. Same goes for electrical problems.
Below I offer an analysis of the merit of the improvements listed in this post, could ask the same from the proponents.
If a lead connected between the engine and the frame somehow fixes an electrical problem, I would be more concerned why the engine to frame mounting points are not providing an adequate electrical connection. Same applies to the starter motor, if one has to add an earth wire between motor and frame then the quality of the mounting should be questioned. Ignition coil mounting bolts have no electrical contact with the ignition system, so adding an earth at these points has no effect.
Only a few components on an NC30/35 rely on an earth through the engine to fame connection. Unless the various mechanical components have become detached from each other, there is no merit in the added earth wiring.
The loom earth wire provides the majority the return points for the electrical components. The reliability of the wiring loop of an NC30/35, or any other bike/car for that matter, should be better that most of the other components of the vehicle, provided that it is well designed and maintained.
Older bikes I suspect could be more reliable than the newer products in the regard, as I believe the internal joins were soldered, whereas the newer versions are crimped. Should the loom be exposure to water, the solder joints will prove better than the crimped type.
Adding extra earth wires might be cheap and simple but if of no benefit, why? Can anyone identify a problem that was cured with this approach, I would be interested to know.